Some of you might recognize my son there in the Bears hat--he's got a big case lid next to him to catch my .223 brass before it smacks him in the face.

(And if you look closely, you can see me digging my left toe into the ground in exactly the fashion I was told not to do.)
I approached this course differently than most. I wanted to bring along my wife and sons because there's been some internet drama between "The Appleseed People" and "The Gun Bloggers" this year, and I thought this was a good chance to get opinions from several people with very different experiences, skill levels and reasons for attending.
- I've been shooting for many years, but never very seriously with rifles. So gun safety is very natural to me, and I have good handling habits and know the terminology, but I'm no rifleman. I used a Colt AR-15 SP1 made in the early 1970's, with A1 sights, GI sling, triangular handguards, the whole deal.
- My wife has only been shooting a few years, and is not nearly as interested in shooting as I am. She came along because, she said, she wanted to share my interest. She planned to use a Jager AP74 (a .22 AR15 clone) but ended up using a loaner Ruger 10/22 when she couldn't locate her magazine.
- Donovan is 12 years old and has very little training beyond safety. He's never really used a rifle without a bench rest, but he loves shooting. He did use a Jager AP74 with one magazine.
- Kane is Donovan's twin brother, and he has severe learning delays along with great difficulty using his hands with coordination. He also has very poor vision and is cross-eye dominant. Kane was the only member of the family who started without iron sights; he wanted to use his favorite rifle, a Marlin Model 60 with a red-dot sight mounted. The Marlin 60 is tube-fed, but the Appleseed program advertises that they will work around such handicaps.
The Good:
The instructors worked very hard with Kane. He was adopted early on by more than one instructor who would spend entire firing strings standing behind Kane and trying to help him. You must understand that while these guys were preaching the tightness of the sling, getting the elbow under the rifle in prone even if you had to yank it painfully across with the other hand (and I did, every time) and perfect breath control, Kane was holding his rifle in his two hands, without even letting the stock touch his shoulder, most of the time. He didn't put a single round on paper the first morning. The instructors had him remove his red-dot sight that morning and try the iron sights, but the truth was, with his vision, he literally could not see the targets. It was hard for him even to see the paper at 25 meters. The next day, we mounted a 3-9x scope on the Marlin and he tried again, but by that time, the Marlin was dying of round count. A friend from SCRA loaned Kane his 10/22 backup with a 3-9x scope and by the end of the day Sunday, Kane was not only on paper but was hitting the 100-yard simulation.
My wife shot day one with a loaner 10/22, but her heart wasn't completely in it. On day two, she came back with us, but told me in the morning that she wouldn't be shooting; she would read her book in the shade and help Donovan if he needed it. We were separated by the berm for the morning, but after lunch I came back down a little late, and what did I see? She was shooting the AQT with her loaner. She's hooked. That was great!
The instruction is intensive and anyone who makes an effort will see improvements.
The Bad:
The instruction is intensive, but I'd rather they make the limitations of what they're doing clear. They're telling the history story throughout the two days, and it's enough to raise goose bumps at times, but what they're teaching is only marksmanship, period. The story they're telling, of the colonial militias raising 14,000 men in 24 hours to win an eventual victory over British regulars, is a story of people trained in tactics, strategy, maneuver, communication, and organization . . . . these were not people who had shot a great score on a difficult rifle target. That was one component of what they accomplished, yes, but by no means does being a good shot mean you're in a position to replicate their feat or anything on the same scale. That is, admittedly, a VERY minor gripe.
Their recommendations as to equipment are very important. They will indeed work with you if you're using a different type of rifle, or if you have no sling. BUT if you show up with an unzeroed rifle (as I did) you're going to have trouble. I don't think I would recommend Appleseed for someone who has never really shot before, as some people do. Yes, it's possible for those people to come in and make big improvements, but although the challenge is addictive, the shooting is very difficult and the positions are uncomfortable and counter-intuitive. I would want someone completely new to go to the range on a quiet day and pop reactive targets for fun before trying something like Appleseed. Appleseed is for people who are good enough to be getting frustrated that they aren't better.
The program has been criticized as being irrelevant to modern combat training. This is true. If you want to learn to clear a block in Fallujah, you probably aren't going to "sling up" for a 100-yard shot, particularly with a standard military sling of today. You probably won't see targets at 200 meters and beyond unless you're a designated marksman. And Appleseed teaches nothing about maneuver, communication, or the other things that make the American army so fearsome today. On the other hand, a lot of the marksmanship ideas do carry over to any shooting, no matter how fast you need to go, and the other important thing Appleseed promotes is intimate knowledge of your rifle.
Things I learned:
- Can't shoot 62-grain ammunition through an older Colt SP1; it will keyhole at 25 meters.
- Two rifles is one; One is none. Have a backup.
- A sling is an excellent aid to marksmanship. I may add a GI sling to my whitetail shotgun.
- My eyes are not what they were. I may break down and use a scope next time.
- The big things in marksmanship are an accumulation of little things that must be done right by habit because there is no time to think about them.
- I really can group 4 MOA consistently in prone.
- However, without a carefully zeroed rifle, a 4moa group still misses a 4moa target completely.
- Appleseed would be an excellent shooting clinic for anyone who shoots NRA High Power competition or wants to start.
- The perfect gun for Appleseed is a Ruger 10/22 with adjustable sights, preferably the ones that adjust like battle rifle sights. Other guns will work, but this is the cheapest, simplest way to go and costs, even including the sights, less than the .223 ammunition I had to buy for my AR15.